Showing posts with label procurement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label procurement. Show all posts

Monday, 20 June 2011

A victory for transparency...and a warning for public sector procurement?

"Organisations tend to be less stupid when they know the public can see how stupid they are." - Nick Booth, Podnosh

Four years ago I was part of an HMG team trying to persuade 43,000 UK public sector organisations to save vast sums of money through buying collaboratively.   Our crusade wasn't exactly an enormous success: simply because back in 2007 saving money wasn't even in the top fifty list of Government priorities. A less sexy agenda it's hard to imagine: back then, noone really gave a fig how money was being spent in the nooks and crannies of the wider public sector: not the media, nor the public, nor local authorities and nor even, frankly, our own Treasury ministers.

Fast forward four years past the financial crisis, the MPs expenses scandal, a general election and Eric Pickles.  Saving money  - or at least, spending money responsibly and accountably - is now top of everyone's agenda. And with the help of the Coalition Government's transparency and open data policy and the huge power of new social media tools and platforms, it has never been easier for the curious or the crusading to find out how much is being spent, and what on.   Today, an ordinary member of the public probably has access to more and better spend information than a senior civil servant sitting in the Office of Government Commerce would have done just a year or two ago.

Whether or not this new transparency is a good thing, however, all depends on who you are and what kind of procurement crimes you may have committed in the last few years.  

As the London Borough of Barnet Council recently discovered...when a group of dogged local "citizen" bloggers managed to unearth evidence  - through FOI requests and Companies House searches - of Barnet Council's rather dodgy "relationship" with a security firm called MetPro (now out of business).  Last week the findings of an internal audit were announced:  including the troubling revelation that the council had spent £1.3 million with MetPro with no tendering exercise, no written contract or SLA, no formal authorisation, no proper invoicing... thus violating just about every CPR that Barnet had.  


Cue some serious questions about Barnet's finance, audit and procurement processes, and some serious embarrassment for the cabinet and senior officers of this so-called "flagship council: especially so given Barnet is one of the councils planning mass outsourcing of services imminently. 

My hunch is that there are two reasons this happened. One, Barnet's service teams and procurement teams aren't talking to each other.  Two, Barnet's procurement team made classic mistakes that could easily have been avoided with a proper central contracts register (which Barnet doesn't have) and some basic supplier intelligence homework (which many local authorities skip through "lack of time"). Barnet didn't do even the most basic of checks before engaging MetPro: financial, criminal, health and safety, nada.  Noone ever picked up that services procured locally with 3 different MetPro trading names were actually all with the same vendor. And corporate procurement only kept a list of the top ten vendor names by spend for each category, not all vendors over tender limits

In the bigger picture, however, this is a wake up call for procurement everywhere. Organisations need to be constantly vigilant that their procurement processess are both A) appropriate and B) being followed - because if they are not, someone else is going to point it out for them, potentially causing huge damage to corporate, political and personal reputations.  There are many communities of developers and digital activists making huge progress cleaning, sorting and making sense of the spend data tsunami coming out of central and local government: such as LinkedGov and Openly Local . For journalists (whether professional or citizen), this stuff is a hundred Christmases come at once. Ominously for Barnet,  the call has already gone out via Twitter for more developers, researchers and digital campaigners to help examine the rest of the council's spending to see if there are any more MetPros on the books.

And just in case you're reading this blog from an ivory tower in the private sector, thanking your lucky stars no FOI requests will be coming your way, think again.  As outsourcing of public services accelerates, the Government is clearly hoping that greater transparency will protect the public against poor value, ill thought through contracts with private sector firms (PFI, anyone?) It is only a matter of time (one more Southern Cross?) before transparency requirements are extended in some shape or form to private firms which provide public services.



PS The final irony of the Barnet case is that one of the duties MetPro performed for Barnet was secretly (or so they thought) filming residents who attended council meetings, and monitoring the blogs of those who wrote about them.  If MetPro had not been as inept and Keystone Cop-pish in their efforts as Barnet were in commissioning them, this particular procurement crime might never have come to light.


Thursday, 16 September 2010

Will you be ready for the data tsunami?

Horribly early the other Saturday morning, I blearily Boris-biked through a completely deserted Fitzrovia to attend Opentech 2010.  It's a refreshingly low-budget (think £5 entry, write-your-own namebadge, one-microphone-between-seven ) low hype conference, which aims to connect various types of geeks interested in how to change the world through data and technology.

This year a big catalyst for discussion was the Coalition Agreement's pledge to create a public "right to data" .  This should be a massive step forward in transparency from the previous government's FOI legislation.  All kinds of public sector data: ranging from procurement contract details to service usage and performance data - should become available to the public for the first time over the next six months.  What's more, the government has promised that our data will be published in a way that will make it clean, comparable, linkable, and above all, useful.  At which point, an army of geeks, entrepreneurs and journalists will move in to analyse the data and ultimately, make money educating, entertaining and alarming the nation with the results.

That's the theory, anyway.

If we lived in France, possibly the most bureaucratic, systematic, hydromatic nation on the planet, this might not be such a challenge.  The French Government has been collecting metric tonnes of data in centrally prescribed, standardised format for years - although there is an equally consistent complete absence of any political will to disclose it.    But  - fortunately or unfortunately, depending on your perspective - our public sector in the UK is a devolved, highly fragmented collection of organisations.    Just on the procurement front alone there are over 44,000 public sector organisations in England that buy things.  All of them record their spend differently, using different software, different formats, different categorisations, different levels of detail: even different names for the same supplier.

"If you build it, he will come"


The task of addressing the mind-bogglingly enormous problem of how to link all this data together has fallen to an admirable group of digital pioneers.  Presenting at Opentech on Saturday, John Sheridan and Jen Tennison of the Cabinet Office data.gov.uk team explained their technical approach to cleaning up submitted data.   The team's hope, as with many of the other presentations at Opentech, is to encourage and inspire geeks to go forth and develop the APIs and applications that will help us all make sense of the gigantic data tsunami soon due to hit the UK.

And they will succeed.  That is to say, spend analysis is a multi million pound industry in the UK.  The same people who have historically made good livings from being given a council's own spend data and selling it back to them in a unique proprietary format have a very strong incentive to find new ways of making money from the right to data.  There are also true transparency champions like Chris Taggart (@countculture) whose site Openly Local already contains partial data from 158 local authorities, and  Hadley Beeman (@hadleybeeman) of LinkedGov.Org


What is of far greater concern - which I sincerely hope is being addressed very seriously by Cabinet Office and DCLG  - is collecting the data in the first place. Yes, data submission deadlines have been set by the Government  - autumn this year for most central government spend data, and January 2011 for local government.   But at present, these deadlines look  hopelessly optimistic.  Many PSOs don't even know themselves what they are buying, who they are buying it from, and how much they are paying - let alone be in a position to report it all to Francis Maude in correct standardised format by Thursday next please.  Small PSOs have never had the technical expertise, and post-Spending Review in November, no PSO will have the time or the resources to prioritise the difficult exercise of identifying, extracting and cleaning up data.


Most importantly - having worked with many local authorities, and regularly witnessed the trials of colleagues in OGC attempting to gather spend data,  I know how difficult it is to impose commands from the center onto the wider public sector.  Even an Eric Pickles shaped transparency stick cannot beat complete clean datasets out of a council if there is no serious will locally.  While PR and marketing has spectacularly fallen out of vogue under the Coalition, there's a very pressing case to direct whatever comms resources are available to selling this to devolved PSOs.  Councils need evidence that extra-organisational linked data can deliver local hard cash savings in order to commit fully - just as they are now beginning to recognise that extra-organisational collaborative procurement will also deliver cash savings.  In both cases, they want to see the gain for their pain.
Powered By Blogger